• Home
  • Custom Cakes
    • Celebration Cake Orders
    • Wedding Cake Orders
    • Cake Gallery
    • Care & Instructions
  • Pastry & Dessert
  • Order
  • About
  • Contact
  • More
    • Home
    • Custom Cakes
      • Celebration Cake Orders
      • Wedding Cake Orders
      • Cake Gallery
      • Care & Instructions
    • Pastry & Dessert
    • Order
    • About
    • Contact
  • Home
  • Custom Cakes
    • Celebration Cake Orders
    • Wedding Cake Orders
    • Cake Gallery
    • Care & Instructions
  • Pastry & Dessert
  • Order
  • About
  • Contact

Your Wedding Cake Journey

Cake Consultation

Not sure where to start? Let's chat! Book a complimentary consultation call to talk through your cake design, flavors, sizing, and delivery or pickup options. We'll make sure every detail is just right before you order.

Schedule Call

Cake Tasting

The best part of the process! Select up to three of our signature flavors to sample for $45, available for pickup at our Sister Bay bakery. It's the perfect way to find your favorites before committing to your cake.

Book Cake Tasting

Cake Ordering

Ready to make it official? Complete our order form below and we'll be in touch within 1–2 business days to confirm your details and get everything in motion.

Order Form

Signature Cake Flavors

We can prepare most flavors using gluten-free ingredients, however the kitchen is not certified gluten-free.

Pure Vanilla Elegance

Vanilla cake with vanilla pastry cream - Vanilla Swiss meringue buttercream

Chocoholic's Dream

Chocolate cake with chocolate pastry cream - Chocolate Swiss meringue buttercream

Sprinkle Celebration

Funfetti cake with funfetti crumble - Birthday cake Swiss meringue buttercream

Tropical Island Vibes

Coconut cake with passion fruit curd & toasted coconut - Coconut Swiss meringue buttercream

Strawberry Fields Forever

Vanilla cake with strawberry compote & brown butter crumble - Vanilla Swiss meringue buttercream

Lemon Kiss

Lemon cake with lemon curd - Lemon Swiss meringue buttercream with meringue kisses

Brown Butter Rhapsody

Brown butter cake with raspberry compote- Brown butter Swiss meringue buttercream

Salted Caramel Decadence

Chocolate cake with salted caramel & salted pretzel crunch - Chocolate Swiss meringue buttercream

Spiced Apple Chai

Chai spiced cake with spiced apples - Coffee Swiss meringue buttercream

London Fog

Earl Grey cake with vanilla bean pastry cream - Citrus Swiss meringue buttercream

Wedding Cake Sizes & Pricing

Single-Tier Cakes

Six Inch Cake - (12-16 Servings) Starts at $135

Eight Inch Cake - (20-24 Servings) Starts at $165

Ten Inch Cake - (30-32 Servings) Starts at $205

Multi-Tier Cakes

Small Two Tiered - 6 inch and 4 inch diameter tiers (16+ servings). Starts at $305

Classic Two Tiered - 8 inch and 6 inch diameter tiers (36+ servings). Starts at $425

Large Three Tiered - 8 inch, 6 inch, and 4 inch diameter tiers (40+ servings). Starts at $545

  • Home
  • Celebration Cake Orders
  • Wedding Cake Orders
  • Pastry & Dessert
  • Order
  • About
  • Contact

Brown Butter Bakeshop

10592 Country Walk Dr UNIT 19, Sister Bay, WI 54234

920-363-2560

Copyright © 2026 Brown Butter Bakeshop - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by

Reopening May 2026!

in Sister Bay, WI. Stay tuned for more details!