Your Celebration Cake Journey Starts Here!
Choose Your Details
Choose Your Details
Choose Your Details
Select your cake size and flavor from our options below. For inspiration, browse our cake portfolio, link below.
Place Your Order
Choose Your Details
Choose Your Details
Order Online: Fill out the form, link below.
Pickup or Delivery
Choose Your Details
Pickup or Delivery
Pickup: From our Sister Bay location. Local Delivery: Available for a fee.
Celebration Cake Sizes & Pricing
Single-Tier Cakes
Six Inch Cake - (12-16 Servings) Starts at $115
Eight Inch Cake - (20-24 Servings) Starts at $150
Ten Inch Cake - (30-32 Servings) Starts at $185
Multi-Tier Cakes
Small Two Tiered - 6 inch and 4 inch diameter tiers (16+ servings). Starts at $205
Classic Two Tiered - 8 inch and 6 inch diameter tiers (36+ servings). Starts at $325
Large Three Tiered - 8 inch, 6 inch, and 4 inch diameter tiers (40+ servings). Starts at $415
EVERY CAKE TELLS A STORY: Browse Our Cake portfolio
Reopening May 2026!
in Sister Bay, WI. Stay tuned for more details!